Hegseth Sparks Backlash Over Combat Standards for Women

On Tuesday, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth addressed senior U.S. military leaders, emphasizing that combat roles should revert to the highest standards traditionally associated with male candidates, even if this results in no women meeting the qualifications for specific positions. His comments during a quickly organized meeting in Virginia sparked renewed backlash regarding his opinions on women serving in the military.

“I have concerns about my son serving with troops who may not be physically fit or in combat units with women who do not meet the same physical standards as men,” Hegseth expressed. “This job is a matter of utmost importance.” It is essential to adhere to established standards.

The statement emerged less than a year following Hegseth’s confirmation, which faced significant challenges due to comparable comments. Since assuming his role, the restructuring of military leadership has notably led to the removal of a substantial number of women, including high-ranking Navy officers and the commandant of the U.S. Coast Guard.

Women veterans have voiced their concerns, emphasizing that combat roles already adhere to a uniform standard for everyone. Elisa Cardnell, president of the Service Women’s Action Network, noted that the demands of infantry roles, including the need to carry heavy equipment and march long distances, apply to both men and women alike.

Capt. Lory Manning, who led Navy units comprising over 400 personnel, stated that women have historically had to demonstrate their capabilities. “Women have had to demonstrate their capabilities before positions were officially available,” she said, noting that “there would have been significant backlash” if women had repeatedly underperformed.

Amy McGrath, a retired Marine fighter pilot, has labeled Hegseth’s assertions as untrue. “There has never been a distinct standard for men and women,” she stated, highlighting that women have consistently met the combat criteria since these positions became available.

Rep. Mikie Sherrill, a former Navy helicopter pilot and Democratic nominee for New Jersey governor, criticized Hegseth, stating he is “the most incompetent secretary of defense we’ve ever had.”

Women within the Republican Party extended support. Senator Joni Ernst, a veteran of the Iraq War, emphasized that equal standards are fitting, while also noting that women currently meet these standards. Rep. Nancy Mace commended Hegseth for his efforts to eliminate diversity and inclusion initiatives, asserting that the military should prioritize mission-first readiness.

Hegseth linked the directives to his broader campaign against specific policies, asserting that leaders who hold opposing views should step down.